Mystery · Audiobook Review

The Thursday Murder Club

by Richard Osman
Our Review

Four retirees, one murder, and the most charming detective squad in recent fiction.

What it is about

Cooper's Chase is a comfortable retirement village in the English countryside. Four residents — Elizabeth, Joyce, Ibrahim, and Ron — meet weekly in the Jigsaw Room to review cold cases. They call themselves the Thursday Murder Club. When a local property developer is found dead with a mysterious photograph beside the body, the club finds itself in the middle of an actual investigation. Osman, a veteran British television presenter, wrote the book over eighteen months without telling anyone. The result is a cozy mystery with more emotional intelligence than the genre usually delivers — these characters are aging, grieving, and fiercely alive, which makes them far more interesting than the usual amateur sleuth.

Narration

Lesley Manville won Audiobook of the Week in The Times for this performance, and the award is deserved. She brings decades of stage and screen experience to the material — each of the four main characters has a distinct voice, rhythm, and register that holds across 12 hours. The comedy lands exactly when it should, and the emotional scenes, which sneak up on the listener more than once, are handled with genuine restraint. CrimeFest named it Best Audiobook of 2021. It is not a coincidence that the series has sold in the millions.

Who it is for

Perfect for commutes, long drives, or any situation where you want something that will hold your attention without demanding it. Ideal for listeners who enjoy Agatha Christie but want more warmth and character depth. Also works well for those who are skeptical of cozy mysteries — this one has more going on than the genre label suggests.

Who should skip it

Skip it if you need pace from the first chapter. The first half of the book is deliberately leisurely — Osman is building his world and his characters before the plot tightens. Listeners who want a thriller rather than a mystery will be frustrated.

Verdict

Listen to it. Lesley Manville is exceptional, the characters are some of the most lovable in recent fiction, and the plot — once it gets moving — delivers genuine surprises. Start the series here.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Lesley Manville won Audiobook of the Week in The Times — one of the finest cozy mystery narrations available
  • Osman balances comedy, warmth, and genuine plot complexity with rare skill
  • The cast of characters is immediately lovable — rare for a debut novel

Cons

  • The first half builds slowly — patience required before the plot accelerates
  • Some listeners find the large cast of characters hard to track on audio
Verdict
Listen to it. The audiobook that launched a series — and Manville is the reason it works so well on audio.
Audible Free Trial
Get this audiobook
free.
30-day trial · cancel anytime · keep your books forever
Start Free Trial →